Defends Surveillance by NYPD, Says Some Muslims Use Religion as Cover

By: Catherine Herridge

Thursday, 15-March-2012

Journalist Asra Nomani is interviewed in suburban Washington.
The New York Police Department has faced criticism for its surveillance of the Muslim community, but one prominent Muslim journalist defended the department in an interview with Fox News.
“We use religion as a cover,” said Asra Nomani, a 46-year-old journalist whose work has been published by the Wall Street Journal and The Daily Beast. Nomani, a native of India, says radical ideology is very real -- and damaging to all Muslims.
“We're saying that you can't go into our mosques, you can't look at our Muslim organizations, you can't even look at Muslims because that's to target us," she told Fox News during an interview in suburban Washington. "But the truth is, we do have a problem in our Muslim community.”
Nomani showed Fox News a Quran from a mosque in West Virginia. She says the Quran’s Saudi publisher added negative language about Jews and Christians. This interpretation of Islam, Nomani says, is part of a larger problem.
“I think that there is a movement in America right now to claim this concept of Islamophobia, to say that people are hating on Islam," she said. "Let's be honest, there are people that do hate on Islam. But I think that (Police Commissioner) Ray Kelly and the New York Police Department have been targeted in this larger campaign to try to show that people are picking on Muslims.”
The New York Police Department's controversial surveillance program involved efforts to infiltrate mosques and Muslim communities on college campuses to gather intelligence on potential threat. News of the secret program has sparked strong reactions, both negative and positive.
Nomani said the Muslim community should take charge: “I think we would be better served by being more proactive rather than defensive.”
Nomani worked with Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl, who was kidnapped and his throat slit by Islamic radicals in Pakistan in February 2002. Pearl’s death was a personal turning point for Nomani in her thinking on religion.
“They did their prayer on the blood-soaked floor of the room where he was murdered. And so, that was when I knew that we needed to challenge how it is that people of supposed faith use religion to sanction their violence," she said.
Nomani, who is co director of the Pearl Project, which investigated the facts surrounding his death, said the search for the killers was eye-opening.
“In our five weeks searching for Danny, what I discovered was that the Pakistani police had no place that was off-limits to them. There was no political correctness in their books about mosques that they couldn't enter," she said.
As for the Attorney General Eric Holder's confirmation last week to lawmakers that his department is reviewing complaints about the NYPD’s surveillance, Nomani was unequivocal: If you draw the line, make it clear that the terrorists are on one side and everyone else is on the other.
“I think that Ray Kelly has a sophisticated understanding of what the problem is, that it's a reality," she said. "And I would tell him to just keep going for it, you know, and really help us clean up our mosques and our communities."

Nomani also has faced a personal cost for her activism, which was profiled in a PBS documentary called “The Mosque in Morgantown.”
“I’ve had death threats," she told Fox News. "I’m not going to be voted most popular at the local mosque. But I think that those are the calculations you have to make when you want to make a difference.”
Asra Q. Nomani is the author of Standing Alone: An American Woman’s Struggle for the Soul of Islam. She is co director of the Pearl Project, an investigation into the murder of Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl. Her activism for women’s rights at her mosque in West Virginia is the subject of a PBS documentary, The Mosque in Morgantown. She recently published a monograph, Milestones for a Spiritual Jihad: Toward an Islam of Grace.

 

 

  
 
 

 

 

 


 

Face to Face

Commander’s View of the Afghan Endgame

In an interview with The New York Times, Gen. Joseph F. Dunford Jr., the supreme military commander in Afghanistan, dis...

Noam Chomsky: Obama's Attack on Civil Liberties Has Gone Way Beyond Imagination

Under Obama's administration, if you meet with someone in a terrorist group and advise them to turn to nonviolent means,...

NATO Commander: ‘Cautious Optimism’ Ahead of Afghanistan Withdrawal

BRUSSELS : The top NATO military commander says, with all the challenges still facing Afghanistan, he is only “cautiousl...

Interview: Afghan opposition leader to president: trust Taliban at your peril

KABUL: Afghan President Hamid Karzai could face the same grisly fate as the last Soviet-backed communist ruler by trusti...

AP INTERVIEW: Top US commander in Afghanistan says he’s working on issues that anger Karzai

KABUL, Afghanistan: The top U.S. military chief in Afghanistan said Monday that his team is working as fast as possible ...

Interview: History Shows You Invade Afghanistan At Your Peril

A new book, "Return of a King: The Battle for Afghanistan 1839-1842," draws on Afghanistan's violent history to provide ...

Interview With Gen. John R. Allen on Leaving Afghanistan

The New York Times interviewed Gen. John. R. Allen on Sunday, a week before his scheduled departure from Afghanistan aft...

Hamid Karzai interview: full transcript

Transcript of the interview with the Afghan president conducted by the Guardian's Emma Graham-Harrison and the ITV News ...

Hamid Karzai: 'I have to be at the frontline of hardship and hard work'

In an exclusive interview with the Guardian in London, the president of Afghanistan explains why he still cannot take a ...

Truth and justice

Pakistan may be one of the most male- dominated societies on the map, with discrimination against women being almost an ...

INTERVIEW-Specter of 2014 haunts Afghan economy, finmin says

WASHINGTON : Worries that instability could undermine the Afghan economy after most foreign troops leave in 2014 could s...

Q. and A. With Former U.S. Commander in Afghanistan

WASHINGTON : As the Obama administration weighs how many troops to keep in Afghanistan after 2014, Gen. Stanley A. McChr...

Interview: Afghanistan braced for withdrawal of foreign forces in 2014

KABUL: Afghanistan is not worried over the withdrawal of the NATO-led foreign troops from the country by the end of 2014...

U.S. Media Elite Honor Female Pakistani Journalist for Her Courage

Zubeida Mustafa was the first woman to work in Pakistan’s mainstream media. That was more than 30 years ago. Today, beca...

Interview: NATO Chief 'Impressed' By Afghan Security Forces

A few days after his visit to Kabul last week, NATO Secretary-General Anders Fogh Rasmussen spoke with RFE/RL Radio Free...

Interview: Trade Can Cure Afghan Opium Addiction

Afghanistan's drug business poses a threat to the entire Central Asian region. But more regional trade, not just tighter...

Afghanistan should be left 'to get on with things' – British ambassador

Sir Richard Stagg suggests process of withdrawal could be accelerated, and says Taliban are ready to talk The internati...

The Deep Divide Over Bagram Prison: Interview With Chris Rogers

The United States has formally handed over control of Bagram prison to Afghan authorities. Yet despite this, U.S. offici...

Interview: Robert Kaplan On How Geography Affects The Fate Of Nations

From Iran's glorious past as the ancient world's first superpower to Russia’s present and continuing obsession with prot...

Are We Winning in Afghanistan?

An exclusive interview with Gen. John Allen, commander of America's forgotten war. The lack of a clearly defined narrat...

Socialists and Writers

Sajjad Zaheer was among those who formed the Progressive Writers’ Association in Lucknow in 1936.SAJJAD ZAHEER, a much-u...

INTERVIEW/ Ma Jun: Is China ready for greening?

In the "factory of the world" that is China; a Beijing-based nongovernmental organization is trying to clean up the envi...

U.S. drought could have global impact on food prices

Jeff Horwich: The weather forecast offers no relief for weeks across much of the U.S. breadbasket. Corn and soybean pric...

Irshad Manji: Love Is the Biggest Threat to Those Who Operate On Fear

‘Thoughts on Being a Modern Muslim’       InterviewDeath threats, bodily harm, living in an apartment with bullet-proof...

AP Interview: Afghan civil war unlikely, US says

KABUL, Afghanistan: The outgoing U.S. ambassador to Afghanistan said Thursday that he thinks it's unlikely that the depa...

Home and the World

Ali Madeeh Hashmi talks to Musharraf Ali Farooqui, author of the recently published novel Between Clay and Dust, about w...

9/11 Was a Turning Point for the American Muslim Community

Last year, while I was the political cartoonist for the Tri-City Voice, a controversy erupted in New York City over a pr...

New Khaki Tactic: Ousting PM Instead of Parliament

The Supreme Court’s verdict to disqualify Prime Minister Yusuf Raza Gillani “is not a routine democratic change”, accord...

Interview: China is Afghanistan's most reliable friend: Chinese Ambassador

KABUL: China is the most reliable friend of Afghanistan, said Xu Feihong, Chinese ambassador to the war-torn country, ju...

Society Must First Seek to Understand Principles of Islam before Applying Them

Society must first seek to understand principles of Islam before attempting to apply them, according to one of Mauritani...

'I don't think we have been defeated'

Bruce Riedel, one of the architects of the US-Afghanistan strategy, is optimistic about the success of NATO’s mission in...

An Interview with Mosque Muslim Leader, Brookfield Physician Mushir Hassan

Mushir Hassan has been living in Brookfield for 12 years, with two daughters in Elm brook schools and two that aren't ye...

Tariq Ali is Still Searching for Socialism with a Human Face

This unrepentant Marxist, writer, journalist, filmmaker and political campaigner is still searching for socialism with a...

INTERVIEW-Afghan Taliban say U.S. must rebuild trust for talks

KABUL: Afghanistan’s Taliban will eventually resume talks with the United States, a former commander said, but it will d...

World must not abandon Afghanistan after combat mission ends, says UK ambassador

British and American troops fighting in Afghanistan "should get out now" if the world's major powers are not prepared to...

A minute with Irrfan, former Irrfan Khan

MUMBAI: Irrfan is probably India's most successful export to Hollywood, having tasted success with experimental roles in...

Michael Muhammad Knight: Religious Laws Can Change

Michael Muhammad Knight in an interview with Richard Marcus Michael Muhammad Knight has earned a reputation as an osten...

Presenter: Secretary of Defense Leon E. Panetta and Daoud Sultanzoy, Tolo Television

DAOUD SULTANZOY: Thank you, Mr. Secretary. SECRETARY LEON PANETTA: Thank you very much. DAOUD SULTANZOY: It's a diff...

Asra Nomani Defends Surveillance by NYPD, Says Some Muslims Use Religion as Cover

March 12, 2012: Journalist Asra Nomani is interviewed in suburban Washington.The New York Police Department has faced cr...

Defends Surveillance by NYPD, Says Some Muslims Use Religion as Cover

Journalist Asra Nomani is interviewed in suburban Washington.The New York Police Department has faced criticism for its ...

Interview: Veteran Diplomat Thomas Ruttig On Implications Of Afghan Massacre

What are the implications of the weekend killings of 16 Afghan civilians by a rogue U.S. soldier in southern Afghanistan...

Ziauddin Sardar On Social Change And Islamic Reform: Can A Minority Of Muslims In Europe Shape New Interpretations Of Islam?

Q. You are obsessed with change. This is in fact, your critics argue, one of the main problems with your thought.     ...

U.S. 'Strong Engagement' To Continue In Central Asia After Afghan Withdrawal

In connection with the U.S.-led mission in Afghanistan, the neighboring countries of Central Asia have moved up in recen...

“Interview with Doctor Laila Hassan’’

1: Tell us something about yourself?• : My name is Dr.Laila Hassan; I did my Post graduate MCPS ENT Training after doing...

Saudi Arabia, The Hidden Uprising

Syed Ali Wasif, President of the Society for International Reforms & Research in an interview with Press TV A Saudi jour...

TIME Exclusive: Q&A with Pakistan Foreign Minister Hina Rabbani Khar

                                                      Since she was appointed as Pakistan's F...

Interview: Afghan analysts say France's early pullout to boost Taliban

KABUL: French President Nicolas Sarkozy's decision to withdraw his forces from Afghanistan by 2013, a year ahead of 2014...

'The Biggest Damage Religion does is Brainwashing Children'

Richard Dawkins in an interview with Vineet GillRichard Dawkins is amongst the most provocative thinkers of our times. T...

Salman Rushdie: “If this is allowed to go on, India will cease to be a Free Country”

Excerpts from Salman Rushdie’s interview to Barkha Dutt of NDTV after the cancellation of his video-link address at the ...

William Milam: Pakistan’s Real Dangers are Internal

The year 2010 witnessed a dramatic deterioration in trust and diplomatic relations between the United States and Pakista...

Don to Dawn: “One of These Days I will come to Pakistan”

That dialogue rings just as true for the man who wears the mask of Don these days; Shah Rukh Khan has been living out of...

INTERVIEW-Afghan cenbank chief focuses on Kabul Bank fix

  * Delawari says tighter supervision needed for banks * Country must bring import activity into banking system * Negot...

We Need to Help Muslims Who are Self-employed

Muzaffarpur-born and Jamshedpur-educated Kashif-ul-Huda is the man behind TwoCircles.net, the website for all things Mus...

An exclusive interview with Afghan President Hamid Karzai

He assesses whether NATO is winning the war effort, explains why he can no longer talk to the Taliban and tells us how h...

Understanding Salafism: an interview with Caucasus Emirate leader Movladi Udugov - Part 2

We have taken up Arms to Establish LawsThis is the second part of Prague Watchdog’s interview with Movladi Udugov. PW: L...

Understanding Salafism: an interview with Caucasus Emirate leader Movladi Udugov - Part I

We Have Taken Up Arms To Establish Laws Movladi Udugov, head of the Informational-Analytical Service of the Caucasus Em...

Sir David Attenborough says geo-engineering solutions to climate change are 'fascist'

Sir David Attenborough, the wildlife presenter, has described high-tech “geo-engineering” solutions to climate change as...

EGYPT AND THE ARAB SPRING: “It’s the Salafis who really worry me”, says Prof. Rashid Khalidi

Following is a transcript of the interview with Rashid Khalidi, Edward Said Professor of Arab Studies at Columbia Univer...

In Defence of the Right to Know

K.N. Panikkar, renowned historian in an interview with G. KrishnakumarA student's right to read Ramanujan's essay on the...

Demand for restoration of previous tax system gains momentum

Business leader terms new income tax return system unsatisfactory Islamabad: Munawar Mughal, Chairman of the Founder Gro...

INTERVIEW-Olympics-Afghanistan trailblazer targets London gold

KABUL :The luxury apartment in north Kabul where Rohullah Nikpai lives with his family was a gift from the Afghan presid...

‘Neither Americans, nor Taliban, build the left’: Aijaz Ahmad

‘Was USSR imperialist? Well, imperialism has to do with capitalism, capitalist accumulation, and transfer of wealth from...

Interview with a Taliban Insider: Iran's Game in Afghanistan

A long-time senior strategist for the Taliban regime who fought under the name Abu Walid al Masri was recently released ...

Devi Shetty, Narayana Hrudayalaya (Heart Specialist)

A chat with Dr.Devi Shetty, Narayana Hrudayalaya (Heart Specialist) Bangalore was arranged by WIPRO for its employees. T...

Ambassador: Afghan attacks 'isolated incidents'

Afghanistan ambassador to Australia Nasir Andisha says there is nothing to suggest the most recent attack by a rogue sol...

IEA economist: ‘We have to leave oil before it leaves us’

The International Energy Agency (IEA)’s annual World Energy Outlook, due for publication on 9 November, will contain ala...

INTERVIEW - Afghan Taliban commander rejects U.S. peace push

CHAMAN, Pakistan: A mid-level Afghan Taliban commander, whose fighters held two French journalists hostage for more than...

Interview Pakistan, US, Afghanistan need joint strategy against terrorism: Gilani

PERTH (Australia): Prime Minister Syed Yusuf Raza Gilani said Pakistan, United States and Afghanistan need to continue w...

Interview: Former U.S. Envoy Says Pakistan Stance Toward Afghanistan Is 'A Problem'

Former U.S. envoy to Afghanistan Zalmay Khalilzad believes the U.S. relationship with Pakistan "has entered a very sensi...

Afghan war: What some local officials are willing to do for peace

Pul-i-Alam, Afghanistan: After spending most of his life as a fighter – first as a mujadhideen during the Soviet invasio...

Afghan Envoy: Taliban Leaders Still A Mystery

As war grinds on in Afghanistan, there is increasing talk about finding a negotiated solution. It's a complicated propos...

Terrorism has no place in any society, says prominent Islamic Scholar Tahir Ul Qadri

Terrorists and those supporting them have no place in any society and they should be banished and brought to justice, a ...

'US has won Afghanistan war'

Interview with Haroun Mir, political analyst, Kabul Dozens of US commandoes have been killed as their helicopter was s...

'Costly errors of US war in Afghanistan'

Interview with Conn Hallinan, a Foreign Policy In Focus columnist In the 10 years since American troops were sent into...

The Curious Case Of The Mullah Omar Meetings

In interviews with RFE/RL's Radio Free Afghanistan, Afghan lawmaker Homa Sultani has repeated the claim that she has met...

Abdul Hakim Elhssadi gives up extremism for true Islam

Abdul Hakim Elhssadi was forced into exile by Moamer Kadhafi. After ending up in Afghanistan and Pakistan, the former Li...

"I am a Witness to the Changes in Islam"

"I am a Witness to the Changes in Islam" Interview with Leading Islamic reformist Nasr Hamid Abu Zaid (1943-2010) Leadi...

Creating Opportunities for Muslim Engagement: An interview with Farah Pandith

It’s almost been a year since Farah Pandith was appointed Special Representative to Muslim Communities by Secretary of S...

‘Healing Wounds’

An interview with Mohammad Umer Daudzai. Mohammad Umer Daudzai was appointed Afghanistan’s ambassador to Pakistan th...

“Netanyahu is the Main Obstacle to Peace”: Jewish activist who disrupted Israeli PM’s Speech to US Congress

RAE ABILEAH, Jewish activist who disrupted Israeli PM’s Speech to US Congress in an interview with AMY GOODMAN Israeli ...

‘Pak army more anti-American than radical’

Dr. Stephen Philip Cohen, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institute, Washington DC, is a respected authority on the Pak...

Struggle of Women for a little More Personal Freedom

Badriya Al-Bishrin, a Saudi writer in an interview with Christoph Dreyer''Anything You Write about Is Made a Scandal, Ev...

Best Way to Combat Terrorism is to Attach Pak’s Economy to India’s: Steve Coll

Steve Coll in an interview with Alia Allana  Award-winning American journalist and writer Steve Coll is the author of be...

Faryal Leghari

Safety parameters on nuclear facilities vital, says expert Former Afghan envoy to the UAE, Farid Zikria, speaks up on ...

Interview: U.S. Congressmen Look To Encourage Afghanistan, Azerbaijan

On their way to visit Baku and Kabul as part of a congressional delegation, U.S. Representatives Bill Shuster (Republica...

Major General Tajammul Hussain Malik: INTERVIEW

I conducted this interview in 2001 September. This is the man who was praised by Indians and they established a commissi...

On guard.

Name:      Egyptian Armed Forces Role: The army remains the most powerful institution in Egypt's chaotic nation, and wha...

Mubarak son Gamal Mubarak

Name:             Gamal Mubarak Age:         47 Role: Served as secretary general of his father's National Democratic Pa...

Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood leader Mohamed Badie

Name: Muslim Brotherhood Role: The brotherhood is Egypt's largest and most organized political opposition movement. Bann...

The Egyptian Nobel Peace Prize winner

 Name:            Mohamed ElBaradei Age:                 68 Role: The Nobel Peace Prize winner joined demonstrators tryi...

Egypt's Civil Aviation Minister Ahmed Shafiq

Name:               Ahmed Shafiq Age:                 69  Role:  President Mubarak appointed Shafiq as prime minister on...

Vice President Omar Suleiman

Name: Omar Suleiman Age: 74 Role: The intelligence chief and Mubarak confidant became Egypt's first vice president in th...

Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak

Name: Hosni Mubarak Age: 82 Role: The former air force commander has ruled Egypt for 30 years as leader of the National ...

Mohammad Atif Khan

Born to a business family in mardan, Muhammad Atif received his high school education from khyber Pukhtunkhwa's most re...


Feature / Analysis

  • بجلی کا مسئلہ بڑی آسانی سے حل ہو سکتا ہے

    نہ صرف لوڈ &...

    Read More »

  • Afghanistan needs India's military help: Shaida Mohammad Abdali

    PUNE : Ambassador of Afghanistan to India, Shaida Mohammad Abdali, sai...

    Read More »

  • Afghanistan to begin first commercial oil production

    Afghanistan expects to begin the first commercial oil production in it...

    Read More »

  • Effort to Strengthen an Afghan Law on Women May Backfire

    KABUL, Afghanistan: Even with some legal protections in place, Afghan ...

    Read More »


Opinion

  • Younger Generation Poised To Lead Afghanistan's Future

    Afghans under 35 make up about 75 percent of the country's population....

    Read More »

  • Did U.S. Assist In Nawaz Sharif Re-election By Pausing Drone Attacks On Pakistan? ‏

    Last publicly reported drone strike was one month ago -"USA Today...

    Read More »

  • Did 9/11 Justify the War in Afghanistan?

    Using the McChrystal Moment to Raise a Forbidden Question -"GR" ...

    Read More »

  • Afghanistan's Karzai seeks Indian military aid amid tensions with Pakistan

    KABUL: Afghan President Hamid Karzai plans to discuss potential arms ...

    Read More »